Shareholder dispute solicitors

Windsor, London & across England & Wales

When co-owners fall out, the business and your investment are both at risk. We resolve shareholder disputes by negotiation where we can and through the courts where we must.

✓ Authorised & regulated by the SRA ✓ Civil and commercial litigation experience ✓ Written cost estimate by stage ✓ Your first call is free

01753 770 775Call anytimeDay or night, someone always answers. Office hours Mon to Fri, 9am to 5pm.

Talk to a disputes solicitorTell us what has happened and a disputes solicitor will call you back, in confidence.

Shareholder Dispute Enquiry

Most shareholder disputes start the same way: a business that worked well between friends, family or co-founders, often two 50/50 owners, and then a disagreement about money, control, company-owned property or the future. Left alone, it damages the company and the value of everyone’s shares.

Judge Law acts for minority and majority shareholders, directors and companies across Windsor, Slough, Maidenhead, Berkshire and London. We look first at what you actually want, whether that is a fair exit, your place back in the business or protection for the company, and then choose the quickest route to it. Most disputes settle. The ones that settle well are those where the other side knows you are ready to go to court.

Shareholder disputes we handle

Deadlock

Two equal shareholders who cannot agree and a board that cannot act. We find the way through, using the articles, the shareholders’ agreement or the court.

Share valuation and exit

Agreeing what your shares are worth and negotiating a buy-out, with an independent valuer where needed.

Exclusion from management

Removed as a director, cut out of decisions or denied information. We act quickly to protect your position and your investment.

Dividends and remuneration

Profits taken as salary or bonuses by some shareholders while dividends to others dry up. We challenge it, or defend it where it is justified.

Unfair prejudice petitions

Bringing or defending a petition under section 994 of the Companies Act 2006, including claims for a court-ordered share purchase.

Derivative claims

Claims brought by a shareholder on the company’s behalf against directors for breach of duty.

Commercial disputes →

Unfair prejudice petitions and derivative claims

Under section 994 of the Companies Act 2006, a shareholder can petition the court where the company’s affairs have been or are being run in a way that is unfairly prejudicial to their interests as a member, or where an act or proposed act would be. Typical examples are exclusion from management in a company run as a quasi-partnership, diverting business or assets, excessive pay in place of dividends and issuing shares to dilute a minority.

If the petition succeeds, the court can make any order it thinks fit under section 996. The most common is an order that the other shareholders, or the company, buy the petitioner’s shares at a fair value. Most petitions settle before trial on exactly those terms.

A derivative claim, under Part 11 of the Act, is different. The shareholder sues on the company’s behalf for a wrong done to the company, such as a director’s breach of duty, negligence or breach of trust. Any money recovered goes to the company, and the shareholder must first obtain the court’s permission to continue the claim.

As a last resort, the court can wind a company up where it is just and equitable to do so. That ends the business, so it is rarely the outcome anyone wants, but it can concentrate minds.

Why instruct Judge Law

  • Litigation backbone. Our team handles civil and commercial litigation, acting both for and against high-value claims.
  • Exit-focused. We keep sight of the outcome you need, which is often a fair price for your shares, not a trial.
  • Corporate know-how. We also draft shareholders’ agreements and run share sales, so we know how the documents should work.
  • Honest costs. Hourly rates with a written estimate for each stage, reviewed as the dispute develops.

How we resolve shareholder disputes

  1. First callA free, confidential first call about what has happened and what you want to achieve.
  2. Review the documentsWe review the articles, any shareholders’ agreement, board minutes and accounts, and advise on your rights and options. Usually within one to two weeks.
  3. Protect your positionRequests for information, steps to stop assets leaving the company and, where needed, urgent applications to court.
  4. NegotiationDirect negotiation or without prejudice offers, often around a buy-out at an agreed valuation.
  5. MediationA mediated settlement day with an independent mediator, which resolves many disputes within weeks rather than months.
  6. Court proceedingsWhere settlement fails, we issue or defend an unfair prejudice petition or derivative claim and take it through to resolution.

Settlement is possible at every stage, and we keep it open throughout.

Falling out with a co-owner?

Your first call is free and confidential, and the earlier we talk, the more options you keep.

How our fees work

Disputes are charged at hourly rates, because no one can fix in advance how the other side will behave. Fixed fees do not fit disputes, and we would rather be straight with you about that.

What we do instead is give you a written estimate for each stage: initial advice, negotiation, mediation and, if needed, court proceedings. We update it as the dispute develops, so you can weigh the cost of each step against what it is likely to achieve. See our fees page for our general approach.

What our initial advice includes

  • Review of the articles and any shareholders’ agreement
  • Review of board minutes, accounts and correspondence
  • Written advice on your rights and the realistic options
  • A strategy and timetable for resolving the dispute
  • A written cost estimate for each stage
  • Letters to the other shareholders or their solicitors

Who does the work

Sonehal Kooner

Sonehal Kooner

Consultant Solicitor

Sonehal Kooner handles all forms of civil and commercial litigation, acting for and against high-value claims, and gives corporate and governance advice across a business’s lifecycle. Her clients include national and global institutions, founders and family offices. She works alongside Partner Naresh Suppal, who brings commercial litigation and dispute resolution experience to the team.

Meet the team →

Shareholder dispute FAQs

Can the other shareholders remove me as a director?
Usually yes. Under the Companies Act 2006, shareholders can remove a director by ordinary resolution at a meeting, with special notice, whatever the director’s contract says. Removal as a director is not the same as losing your shares, though. If you were excluded from a business run on a shared understanding that you would be involved, you may have an unfair prejudice claim.
Will my dispute end up in court?
Most shareholder disputes settle without a trial, often through negotiation or mediation, and frequently by one side buying the other out. Being properly prepared for court is what makes a good settlement possible, so we build your case from the start while keeping every route to agreement open.
What are my shares worth?
It depends on the articles, any shareholders’ agreement and how the company has been run. A key question is whether a minority shareholding should be discounted for lack of control. That is often the heart of the negotiation. We usually work with an independent valuer and make sure the basis of valuation is argued properly.
They are paying themselves instead of paying dividends. What can I do?
Directors have a wide discretion over dividends, but taking profits as excessive salaries or bonuses while minority shareholders get nothing can be unfairly prejudicial conduct. We start by obtaining the accounts and board records, then put the other side on notice. Many of these cases settle once the numbers are laid out.
What is an unfair prejudice petition?
It is an application to court under section 994 of the Companies Act 2006 by a shareholder whose interests have been unfairly harmed by the way the company is run. If it succeeds, the court can make any order it thinks fit. Most commonly, it orders the purchase of the petitioner’s shares at a fair value.
How much will a shareholder dispute cost?
It depends on how the other side responds and how far the dispute goes. We charge hourly and give you a written estimate for each stage, from initial advice to mediation and court. Early advice is money well spent: it often avoids steps that would cost far more later.
How do I protect my share of the business?
Act early. Keep copies of the accounts, board minutes and key correspondence, and do not resign as a director or sign anything without advice. Where the company owns property or other valuable assets, we can press for undertakings that nothing is sold or charged while the dispute is resolved. Delay can let value leave the company and narrow your options.
How do I get out of a 50/50 company?
First check the articles and any shareholders’ agreement for transfer, pre-emption or deadlock provisions. Without them, the usual exit is a negotiated buy-out by the other shareholder or the company, at a value agreed or set by an independent valuer. If the other side refuses to engage, the threat of an unfair prejudice petition or a winding-up application often brings them to the table.

What our clients say

4.7 out of 5 from 130 Google reviews

Having worked with AJ over the last few months I can highly recommend him and his firm. Highly professional and explaining each step only the way.

Tess S.Google review · Nov 2026

I cannot recommend Judge Law highly enough. Going through a divorce is never easy, particularly when there is a child and complex matters involved, but the support and guidance I received throughout the process made a difficult time much easier to navigate. I felt listened to…

natasha P.Google review · Nov 2026

Excellent service from AJ. AJ looked after us with regular updates and quick responses. He got the job done as efficiently as possible and we’re very happy with the service received. Thank you

Mike W.Google review · Nov 2026

Excellent service, couldn’t have asked for. Helped me get my first house and made it really simple during the process definitely would recommend

Raydwaan K.Google review · Oct 2026

I can’t recommend Judge Law highly enough. We were referred to them and chose to instruct Judge Law because of their responsiveness — we had a very short window to complete due to lender demands, and they gave us confidence from the outset that they could move at the pace…

Ghunzanfur K.Google review · Oct 2026

F.A.O. Abdurrahman Jawzi (AJ) - Judge Law As first time buyers with no legal expertise, the conveyancing process was daunting. Following conversations with work colleagues/friends/family we were flooded with negative reviews of legal firms they had used quoting poor customer…

Dan N.Google review · Oct 2026

Related corporate and commercial services

Talk to us about your dispute

Call 01753 770 775 or tell us what has happened and a disputes solicitor will come back to you, in confidence.

Shareholder Dispute Enquiry